Fifth scan in 18 months, and this time I walked in half expecting bad news.
The scale hasn’t moved since March. Seven months of sitting around 71kg, after a year of steady progress, makes it hard not to wonder whether the effort has stopped working.
For anyone new here, I started DEXA scans because I wanted to know where my bone health stood, rather than waiting until the standard age of 65 to find out. I also wanted a proper picture of my body composition, because the scales are a terrible way to measure what’s actually happening in your body. You can catch up on my first scan and my three-month update for the full backstory.
So why hasn’t the scale moved?
Because the scale can’t tell the difference between fat, muscle, water and everything else. Over the last seven months, I’ve lost fat and gained muscle at roughly the same rate, so the total weight stayed put while my body changed shape underneath it. My body fat dropped from 28.6% to 27.3%, and my muscle is the highest it’s been across all five scans.
A small caution on that. DEXA counts water and stored carbohydrate as lean mass, and I’d been eating more for four weeks before the scan, so some of the gain could be fluid. I’m not claiming every gram is muscle. But the important part is that I haven’t lost any while losing fat, which is the hard bit in perimenopause.
The change I’m happiest about
My visceral fat dropped from 58 to about 40, well inside the optimal range. My exercise physiologist, Dr Sven, said it was the biggest drop of anything on my report.
This is the fat wrapped around your organs, not the kind you can pinch, and it matters most for long-term health. As he explained last time, the lower it goes, the better your body responds to insulin, which makes everything easier to maintain. It dropped the most while the scale did nothing, which is exactly why I don’t trust the scale anymore.
The bit I wish I could skip
Last time I told you my bone density was improving. This time my lower spine is down 2.2% since I started. It’s still normal, my fracture risk hasn’t gone up, and Dr Sven isn’t worried. He said he’d start paying attention if it dropped 5 or 6%.
I’d be cherry-picking if I only shared the good news. Part of the explanation is that losing weight means carrying less load, and bone responds to load. That’s one reason I’m lifting heavier, and I’ll keep an eye on it with my doctor and at my next scan.
Why my legs are being so stubborn
My upper body and trunk have changed much faster than my legs. Dr Sven explains that women hold fat in different places, and my legs are where I naturally store it, so they’re the last to move. About half of my body fat is sitting in them.
I’ve also booked in with an occupational therapist who works with lipoedema, just to rule it in or out. I’m not assuming anything; I just want to know.
What happens now
Here’s what has changed. After years of being told to eat less, Dr Sven wants me to eat more.
His reasoning is that I’m training hard and need to fuel it. If I give my body enough food to build muscle and recover from heavy sessions, it should keep pulling the shortfall from stored fat on its own, without me forcing a deficit. He wants to see another 1 to 2kg shift at my next scan before we even talk about cutting. If I do cut later, the goal for leg definition is gentle and slow.
So I’m keeping my three classes, adding a heavy leg day at home, and easing back into running. The running isn’t for fat loss. It’s for my heart and fitness, and I’m doing it as run/walk intervals, because jogging slowly turned out to send my heart rate through the roof.
If you’re in perimenopause and stuck
A stalled scale doesn’t always mean a stalled body. Mine said nothing had changed, and the scan said otherwise. If you’ve plateaued, find a way to measure more than weight.
If you've been following along and thinking "okay, but what did she actually DO?", it's all in Choose Yourself. It's the full rebuild, written down: the nine things that moved the needle, the DEXA scans, HRT, lifting heavy, the gut stuff, the GLP-1 decision, and the many, many things that didn't work. It's not a 30-day glow-up or a meal plan you'll abandon by Thursday. It's what I wish someone had handed me in 2021, when I thought this was just what midlife felt like.
Have you ever been stuck on the scale while something else was changing? I’d love to hear where you’re at.






